Civil Rights Cases

Also found in: Wikipedia.

Civil Rights Cases

A landmark decision, which was a consolidation of several cases brought before the Supreme Court of the United States in 1883 that declared the civil rights act of 1875 (18 Stat. 336) unconstitutional and ultimately led to the enactment of state laws, such as Jim Crow Laws, which codified what had previously been individual adherence to the practice of racial Segregation. The cases were United States v. Stanley, United States v. Ryan, United States v. Nichols, and United States v. Singleton, 109 U.S. 3, 3 S. Ct. 18, 27 L. Ed. 835.

The Civil Rights Act of 1875 was passed by Congress in the post-Civil War era in response to the refusal of many whites to afford newly freed slaves equal treatment with whites under federal law. The act mandated that owners of public facilities, such as inns, restaurants, railroads, and other carriers, not discriminate against blacks who sought access to, or service from, them on the basis of their race. Anyone who violated the law was subject to criminal prosecution.

Scores of prosecutions ensued and six cases reached the Supreme Court. The fact patterns of the cases were comparable in that they all were predicated upon the failure of blacks to be treated the same as whites in various establishments such as restaurants, theaters, railroads, and even the New York City Grand Opera House.

The Court consolidated these cases by deciding that the crucial issue in each was whether the Civil Rights Act of 1875 was constitutional, to which it answered "no." In an 8–1 decision, Justice joseph bradley reasoned that neither the Thirteenth nor Fourteenth Amendments empowered Congress to safeguard blacks against the actions of private individuals. To decide otherwise would afford blacks a special status under the law that whites did not enjoy. The Thirteenth Amendment's prohibition of Slavery had no application to discrimination in the area of public accommodations. Neither did the equal protection clause of the Fourteenth Amendment apply to prohibit racial segregation, since it was as the result of conduct by private individuals, not state law or action, that blacks were suffering.

The only dissenting justice was John Marshall Harlan, who criticized the majority opinion on a number of grounds, including that the exclusion of blacks from state licensed facilities for no other reason than their race did bring into application both the Thirteenth and Fourteenth Amendments and that Congress had the authority pursuant to the Commerce Clause to legislate in those cases involving railroads.

The decision in the Civil Rights Cases severely restricted the power of the federal government to guarantee equal status under the law to blacks. State officials in the South took advantage of the eclipsed role of Congress in the prohibition of racial discrimination and proceeded to embody individual practices of racial segregation into laws that legalized the treatment of blacks as second-class citizens for another seventy years.


Civil Rights; Civil Rights Acts; "Civil Rights Cases" (Appendix, Primary Document).

References in periodicals archive ?
After launching a law practice in Montgomery in 1960, he won a series of groundbreaking civil rights cases that helped integrate government and public institutions.
As attorney general, her earliest tests will likely include handling civil rights cases stemming from deadly altercations between police and unarmed black men in several US cities.
I began this analysis by suggesting that recent scholarship has shown that the conventional history of the Supreme Court's role in interpreting the Reconstruction Amendments in civil rights cases needs refinement.
International standards The official disclosed that most of the crimes committed by the Omani inmates are either road accidents that resulted in fatalities, thefts or civil rights cases.
The legal landscape looks similar to what the court confronted when it took on earlier major civil rights cases.
Crist brought Villalobos the bill to sponsor because, as the senator said, "They've had to go the long way around the building" to take on civil rights cases.
There are currently 11 open police civil rights cases that are in various stages of litigation.
Career Highlights: Rice is acclaimed for litigating civil rights cases involving police misconduct, employment discrimination, and fair public resource allocation.
Attorney Jeffrey Needle of Seattle, who represents plaintiffs in civil rights cases, said that taping could be a powerful tool in whistleblowing litigation but could have negative repercussions in the short term.
For lawyers to have the guts to go into Alabama and Mississippi in 1962 and argue civil rights cases, that takes courage.
The voters seem to consent to irresponsible leadership and are apathetic about conflicts of interest concerning the landfill in Granada Hills and civil rights cases for false arrest, which will cost Los Angeles millions.

Full browser ?