Preponderance of Evidence


Also found in: Dictionary, Thesaurus, Medical, Financial, Encyclopedia, Wikipedia.
Related to Preponderance of Evidence: burden of proof, Clear and convincing evidence

Preponderance of Evidence

A standard of proof that must be met by a plaintiff if he or she is to win a civil action.

In a civil case, the plaintiff has the burden of proving the facts and claims asserted in the complaint. If the respondent, or defendant, files a counterclaim, the respondent will have the burden of proving that claim. When a party has the Burden of Proof, the party must present, through testimony and exhibits, enough evidence to support the claim. The amount of evidence required varies from claim to claim. For most civil claims, there are two different evidentiary standards: preponderance of the evidence, and clear and convincing evidence. A third standard, proof Beyond a Reasonable Doubt, is used in criminal cases and very few civil cases.

The quantum of evidence that constitutes a preponderance cannot be reduced to a simple formula. A preponderance of evidence has been described as just enough evidence to make it more likely than not that the fact the claimant seeks to prove is true. It is difficult to translate this definition and apply it to evidence in a case, but the definition serves as a helpful guide to judges and juries in determining whether a claimant has carried his or her burden of proof.

The majority of civil claims are subjected to a preponderance of evidence standard. If a court or legislature seeks to make a civil claim more difficult to prove, it may raise the evidentiary standard to one of clear and convincing evidence.

Under some circumstances use of the low preponderance of evidence standard may be a violation of constitutional rights. For example, if a state seeks to deprive natural parents of custody of their children, requiring only proof by a preponderance of evidence is a violation of the parents' due process rights (Santosky v. Kramer, 455 U.S. 745, 102 S. Ct. 1388, 71 L. Ed. 2d 599 [1982]). Freedom in matters of family life is a fundamental liberty interest, and the government cannot take it away with only a modest evidentiary standard. However, a court may use a preponderance of evidence standard when a mother seeks to establish that a certain man is the father of her child (Rivera v. Minnich, 483 U.S. 574, 107 S. Ct. 3001, 97 L. Ed. 2d 473 [1987]). Most states use the preponderance of evidence standard in these cases because they have an interest in ensuring that fathers support their children.

Further readings

Orloff, Neil, and Jery Stedinger. 1983. "A Framework for Evaluating the Preponderance-of-the-Evidence Standard." University of Pennsylvania Law Review 131 (April).

Slatkin, Stephanie. 1997. "The Standard of Proof at Sentencing Hearings Under the Federal Sentencing Guidelines: Why the Preponderance of the Evidence Standard is Constitutionally Inadequate."

Cross-references

Clear and Convincing Proof.

References in periodicals archive ?
Should preponderance of evidence be the proof standard in these cases?
When Lincoln's cousin is charged with a brutal crime, and a preponderance of evidence suggests his guilt despite his claims of innocence, Lincoln's investigation uncovers the machinations of an evil man who plucks the system's strings to frame others for his rapes and murders.
The preponderance of evidence supports the fact that COX-2 inhibitors are far superior to COX-1 inhibitors in terms of decreasing gastrointestinal side effects.
There was a great deal of evidence presented, and the preponderance of evidence in my mind says that we have an acceptable risk to go fly," shuttle program manager Wayne Hale said Tuesday.
Government prosecutors said they expect a guilty verdict based on the preponderance of evidence they have presented in court.
Risk of death was related to CD4 count but not feeding method, (1) The preponderance of evidence is that HIV-positive women are not compromised by breastfeeding and as formula-fed infants are more likely to die of causes other than HIV, replacement feeding has not reduced the overall risk of infant mortality.
The resulting Supreme Court certification was limited solely to establishing the appropriate standard of proof for an IFPA violation, and the Court determined that the standard was "a preponderance of evidence," the least demanding of the three evidentiary standards (preponderance of evidence, clear and convincing evidence, and proof beyond a reasonable doubt).
The Workers' Compensation Commission found that Nurse Holland failed to prove by a preponderance of evidence that she sustained a compensable injury for which her employer was responsible.
As Andrea Neal pointed out in her January 18 Indianapolis Star column, "the preponderance of evidence suggests that township government is a drain on Hoosier taxpayers.
Scholl proves to have been a pretty good liar, almost talking her way out of custody until the preponderance of evidence forces her to acknowledge underground affiliations.
The preponderance of evidence suggests that the warming of the past 50 years has mostly come from greenhouse gas emissions and everything we're seeing in the Arctic is 100 percent consistent with that," says Robert Corell, a senior fellow at the American Meteorological Society in Washington, D.
It decided that if a worker proves by a preponderance of evidence that sex was a motivating factor in the employer's decision or action, the worker is entitled to damages, even when the employer also is motivated by lawful reasons, unless the employer can demonstrate that it would have treated the worker similarly had gender played no role.