The form of peer review
that a journal uses--open, single-blind, or double-blind--and the details of the review process are vital aspects of proper peer-review ethics and etiquette, in addition to overall journal quality.
Standards for Performing and Reporting on Peer Review
The price for failing to recognize that sham peer review
exists, and that there are physicians and hospital administrators who view sham peer review
as a "useful tool" to eliminate certain physicians, is often the death of a good physician's career.
We both ask tutors facilitating in-class workshops to explain that student peer review
emulates peer review
in academic publication and/or daily workplace reviews of colleagues' writing, since peer review
becomes most valuable when students understand it both as a classroom activity that can improve their critical reading and writing skills and as a real-world process in which writers address the needs of their audiences.
It is evident that federal courts believe the interests in enforcing laws against antitrust violations, employment discrimination, and fraud outweigh any public policy benefits favoring a privilege for medical peer reviews
The risk management committee report/minutes may also include recommendations for the MTF credentials committee for privilege/practice related actions (potentially initiating the alternative track of peer reviews
that occur under the professional review system established in chapter 10, Army Regulation 40-681(p76)).
AICPA Standards for Performing and Reporting on Peer Reviews
More than 80 percent of the respondents rated AllMed excellent or above average in these seven categories: overall quality; credentials of peer review
specialists; thoroughness; turn-around time; availability of medical staff; responsiveness, and customer service.
The draft culminates several years of work in which special task forces and the AICPA Board of Directors thoroughly reviewed the current AICPA Peer Review
Program to ensure it was meeting the original goals for which it was created--continually enhancing the quality of accounting, auditing and attestation services performed by AICPA members in public practice.
It is not yet clear whether the peer reviews
The compromise, he said, was to create the new committee, ending appeals to the board, and give the new panel access to the peer reviews
Program effectiveness is also achieved when various constituencies believe that peer reviews
do achieve the goals of the program.