test case

Also found in: Dictionary, Thesaurus, Medical, Acronyms, Encyclopedia, Wikipedia.
Related to test case: Test scenario

Test Case

A suit brought specifically for the establishment of an important legal right or principle.

The term test case describes a case that tests the validity of a particular law. Test cases are useful because they establish legal rights or principles and thereby serve as precedent for future similar cases. Test cases save the judicial system the time and expense of conducting proceedings for each and every case that involves the same issue or issues.

To illustrate, assume that Congress passes a law that makes using a cellular phone while driving a misdemeanor punishable by up to one year in jail and a fine of $10,000. Such a law would likely be challenged by a large number of cell phone owners, all of whom are in essentially identical circumstances and all of whom have the same arguments against the law. In such a situation, attorneys representing the plaintiffs might look for a case with a sympathetic set of facts with which to challenge the law. For example, they might select a case involving a driver who was charged with violating the law when she used her cell phone to request medical assistance for a family member. Other observant law firms would postpone or otherwise delay their own similar cases to wait for the outcome of the test case.

A test case need not concern a new law. Suppose, for example, an attorney or client is dissatisfied with the current state of a particular law and has strong arguments in favor of changing it. If the facts of the case give the attorney or client a good chance of prevailing, the case may be called a test case because the outcome would change the law for future persons in similar circumstances.

In some cases, a person may choose to violate an existing law to provoke a lawsuit, prosecution, or penalty. The person may then challenge the lawsuit, prosecution, or penalty and use the case to try and change the law through a judicial opinion. In Druker v. Commissioner of Internal Revenue, 697 F.2d 46 (2d Cir. 1982), cert. den., 461 U.S. 957, 103 S. Ct. 2429, 77 L. Ed. 2d 1316 (1983), for example, James O. and Joan Druker, a married couple, intentionally used the lower tax rates for unmarried individuals in computing their 1975 and 1976 Income Tax because they believed the federal tax scheme was unconstitutional under the equal protection clause of the Fourteenth Amendment. Before the Internal Revenue Service (IRS) could take action against the Drukers, the Drukers filed suit against the commissioner of the IRS. The Drukers were unsuccessful, but had they received a favorable disposition, they would have succeeded in changing the law on federal taxation of married couples.


Case Law; Stare Decisis.

See: criterion

test case

References in periodicals archive ?
The other test case against Traveler's Insurance Company is still pending.
Anite s fully automated Conformance Toolset solution uses the internal baseband fading capabilities of the Anite 9000 network simulator, enabling existing users to easily and cost-effectively access the new PTRCB data throughput test cases.
Moreover, the integrated approach also addresses the impact of business requirement changes on test cases (which is typical in the ERP project cycle or maintenance).
The other test cases are former Sky Sports pundit Andy Gray, Labour MP Chris Bryant, celebrity agent Sky Andrew and interior designer Kelly Hoppen.
Before the test cases were resolved, however, the IRS secretly settled with two of the test case taxpayers on terms more favorable than those generally offered to other taxpayers.
In order to try the large number of cases efficiently, the IRS, the attorney hired by Kersting, and the Tax Court agreed to use the test case procedures and chose to try eight test cases.
NEARLY one million consumers have had claims for bank charge refunds worth an estimated pounds 713m frozen while a test case goes through the courts.
Ken Krieg, under secretary of defense (acquisition, technology and logistics), laid out a plan in April 2006 for "gaming" the ERAM concept through a set of initial test case systems: the Defense Integrated Military Human Resources System; the General Fund Enterprise Business System; and the Integrated Data Environment/Global Transportation Network Convergence.
The Canadian Bar Association has chosen British Columbia to launch a test case to establish a constitutional right to civil legal aid in British Columbia because it has instituted the most drastic cuts in assistance to low income persons.
This special report describes anomalies detected among the test cases, the testing environment, and expected results; presents results of 35 test assertions; and includes summary log files for each test case.
Because of the complexity and ambiguity, most testing methodology documents require the development of a set of test case scenarios (e.
The FMS test cases will be initially structured with separate lines allocating 80 percent of the test case value to the traditional FMS process and 20 percent to the hybrid process.