Contingent Fee

Also found in: Dictionary, Thesaurus, Medical, Wikipedia.

Contingent Fee

Payment to an attorney for legal services that depends, or is contingent, upon there being some recovery or award in the case. The payment is then a percentage of the amount recovered—such as 25 percent if the matter is settled, or 30 percent if it proceeds to trial.

Contingent-fee agreements are valid only in civil cases and are frequently used in personal injury cases. Court rules and statutes often regulate these fees in relation to the type of action and amount of recovery. Such an arrangement is generally used when the party seeking recovery cannot afford to retain an attorney and therefore would not have any effective means of prosecuting a claim.

An attorney is not entitled to a contingent fee in the absence of an express contract. Contingent-fee agreements, although intensively scrutinized by the courts, are valid if equitable and reasonable to the client. The purpose of a contingent fee is to reward attorneys for proficiency and diligence in prosecuting disputed and litigated claims, as opposed to rendering minor services that any inexperienced attorney might perform.

Contingent fees are never permitted in criminal cases, as there is no possibility of a financial recovery that would be the source of the contingent fee. These arrangements are emphatically discouraged in Divorce proceedings due to public policy considerations. An attorney may discourage a reconciliation if a fee depends upon the granting of a divorce. Public policy favors the continuation of marriage, which is traditionally viewed as a stabilizing force in society. A contingent-fee contract that prohibits a client from settling a case is also void as against public policy because society views the avoidance of unnecessary litigation as desirable.

When an attorney who was retained on a contingent-fee basis dies, his or her estate will not be entitled to any fee unless the attorney had completely performed the contract prior to death. In some states, the estate cannot recover unless the jury had returned a monetary award in favor of the client before the attorney's death. However, the attorney's personal representatives may collect payment for the reasonable services that were rendered.

An attorney might be entitled to recover his or her share of the proceeds of an action if the contingent-fee contract was substantially performed prior to the death of the client. If the case had been submitted to the jury before the client died, and the jury found in favor of the client, the attorney is entitled to his or her fee from the proceeds. If the suit is dismissed or settled by the client's personal representatives, the attorney might have no right to a fee unless the contract so provided. However, the death of a client does not deprive an attorney of the right to recover the reasonable value of his or her services rendered until the time of the client's death.

Jurisdictions are not unanimous as to the question of whether an attorney's contingent fee should be calculated based on the net amount of the recovery that a client actually receives or the gross amount of recovery before any successful counterclaims are factored in. For example, suppose that a personal-injury lawyer agrees to represent the plaintiff for a one-third contingent fee and recovers a $100,000 jury verdict. However, the jury also returned a verdict on the defendant's counterclaim for $10,000. Should the plaintiff's lawyer receive a $33,000 contingent fee or a $30,000 contingent fee?

Section 35 of the Restatement (Third) of the Law Governing Lawyers provides that "when a lawyer has contracted for a contingent fee, the lawyer is entitled to receive the specified fee only when and to the extent the client receives payment." Comment d to section 35 provides that "[i]n the absence of [a] prior agreement to the contrary, the amount of the client's recovery is computed net of any offset, such as a recovery by an opposing party on a counterclaim." To date, Section 35 has been adopted only in Texas. Other states calculate the fee based on the client's full award, regardless of whether the client ever actually recovers the full amount awarded, reasoning that such a calculation better reflects the comprehensive value of the attorney's services and the economic value received by the client.

West's Encyclopedia of American Law, edition 2. Copyright 2008 The Gale Group, Inc. All rights reserved.

contingent fee

n. a fee to a lawyer which will be due and payable only if there is a successful conclusion of the legal work, usually winning or settling a lawsuit in favor of the client (particularly in negligence cases), or collecting funds due with or without filing a lawsuit. In many states, such agreements must be in writing signed by attorney and client. The fee is generally a percentage of the recovery (money won), but may be partly a fee for time worked and partly a percentage. Although fees are negotiable, a standard contingent fee in accident cases is one-third of the money won, unless particular difficulties exist with the case, making the attorney believe he/she has the right to ask for more. States vary but some put a cap on the amount of fee for cases handled for minors even if the parent as guardian at litem agrees to more. Contingent fee agreements in criminal cases which depend on the outcome are unethical.

Copyright © 1981-2005 by Gerald N. Hill and Kathleen T. Hill. All Right reserved.
References in periodicals archive ?
The court considered the contingent fee agreement, noting that it is a good indication of the risk for an attorney in taking a condemnation case.
"As to the second argument, the fact that a contingency contemplated in HLO's fee agreement with Hicks settlement eventually came to pass also has no bearing on when HLO's cause of action for legal fees against Hicks accrued, because Hicks's discharge of HLO terminated HLO's right to recover on the contingent fee agreement.
A more egregious conflict of interest would result if a judge or arbitrator were not only contracted by the plaintiff but also compensated under a contingent fee arrangement by the plaintiff, and therefore paid based on a percentage of the financial judgment awarded to the plaintiff against the defendant.
An extraordinary lien and subrogation lawyer may charge fees for extraordinary lien and subrogation resolution services that, when combined with the fees for the underlying personal injury or wrongful death matter, exceed the contingent fee schedule set forth in this rule only if the services are in the client's best interests, only after obtaining the client's written informed consent to the fees, and only after prior court approval as specified below.
Alternative and contingent fees, on the other hand, include the outside lawyer as a decision maker about what to do; a lawyer on a contingent fee isn't obliged to do work merely because you want it done if the lawyer doesn't think it's needed.
A partial solution proposed by Michael Johnson is that plaintiffs are charged a registration fee in advance for contingent fee lawsuits, even though this could be viewed as a contradiction in terms.
With a contingent fee arrangement, there is generally no immediate "hit" or expense to a business unit's or tax department's budget for the incremental cost of performing the study.
1997) (person may not act as appraiser or expert witness and present expert testimony under contingent fee agreements); Cresswell v.
Circular 230, Section 10.27(b) (2), does allow a contingent fee arrangement between the practitioner and taxpayer in certain situations.
(15.) Eyal Zamir & Ilana Ritov, Notions of Fairness and Contingent Fees, 74 LAW & CONTEMP.
Commissions and contingent fees are acceptable in specific circumstances, but referral fees are not acceptable unless the CPA is paying a fee for obtaining clients in conjunction with the purchase of an accounting practice.

Full browser ?