In Pari Delicto


Also found in: Financial, Wikipedia.

In Pari Delicto

[Latin, In equal fault.] A descriptive phrase that indicates that parties involved in an action are equally culpable for a wrong.

When the parties to a legal controversy are in pari delicto, neither can obtain affirmative relief from the court, since both are at equal fault or of equal guilt. They will remain in the same situation they were in prior to the commencement of the action.

in pari delicto

adv. (in pah-ree dee-lick-toe) Latin for "in equal fault," which means that two (or more) people are all at fault or are all guilty of a crime. In contract law, if the fault is more or less equal then neither party can claim breach of the contract by the other; in an accident, neither can collect damages, unless the fault is more on one than the other under the rule of "comparative negligence"; in defense of a criminal charge, one defendant will have a difficult time blaming the other for inducing him or her into the criminal acts if the proof is that both were involved.

IN PARI DELICTO. In equal fault; equal in guilt. Neither courts of law nor equity will interpose to grant relief to the parties, when an illegal agreement has been made, and both parties stand in pari delicto. The law leaves them where it finds them, according to the maxim, in pari delicto potior est conditio defendentis et possidendis. 1 Bouv. Inst. n. 769.

References in periodicals archive ?
Q: Is the doctrine of in pari delicto applicable in this ejectment case?
CRIMINAL LAW--Second Circuit Applies Defense of in Pari Delicto to Racketeer Influence Corrupt Organization Act Claim--Republic of Iraq v.
1) In pari delicto is a well-established common law defense, applicable to federal statutes, that bars plaintiffs from recovery when the plaintiff bears substantial fault and responsibility for the wrongdoing.
Under the doctrine of in pari delicto ("in equal fault"), an auditor cannot lie held liable for negligently failing lo detect wrongdoing or lor even participating in die wrongdoing if the corporation also participated at least equally.
An auditor's success in using the in pari delicto defense varies significantly, depending on the applicable law of the stale in which die lawsuit is filed.
One of the strongest legal weapons available to audit firms sued by shareholders or creditors following revelations of corporate fraud is the defense of in pari delicto, This legal doctrine, over two centuries old, is grounded in the policy that a court should not intercede between two wrongdoers.
The in pari delicto doctrine is raised in all of these cases.
30) The defense of in pari delicto prohibits a party from recovering damages arising from misconduct for which the party bears responsibility.
In pari delicto would not apply if the plaintiff showed she was acting under the defendant's compulsion.
27) Conceptually, the in pari delicto defense will apply "where the fault of the parties is mutual, simultaneous and relatively equal, and where the plaintiff is an active, essential, and knowing participant in the unlawful activity.
Faced with malpractice actions because of the fraud of their clients, some attorneys have employed defenses based on theories of in pari delicto, estoppel, and contributory or comparative negligence.
Under the in pari delicto principle, public policy dictates that parties who both transgress the law should not be permitted to profit from their wrongdoing.