Legal Certainty

Legal Certainty

A test in Civil Procedure designed to establish that a complaint has met the minimum amount in controversy required for a court to have jurisdiction to hear the case. Under this test, if it is apparent from the face of the pleadings, to a "legal certainty" that the plaintiff cannot recover or was never entitled to the amount in the complaint, then the case will be dismissed.

For example, the existence of federal diversity jurisdiction on the part of a federal district court—one aspect of which is the presence of an amount in controversy in excess of $75,000—is a threshold Question of Law, or one which must be determined by the judge at the start of the action by applying the legal-certainty test.

Further readings

Glannon, Joseph W. 2001. Civil Procedure: Examples and Explanations. Gaithersburg, Md.: Aspen Law & Business.

Kane, Mary Kay. 1996. Civil Procedure in a Nutshell. 4th ed. St. Paul, Minn.: West Group.


Amount in Controversy; Dismissal; Jurisdiction.

Mentioned in ?
References in periodicals archive ?
Due to the necessity that the FMSA must be willing to arrange with the necessary legal certainty in the presence of the processing conditions relating to an institution within the scope of A* 1 SAG all the necessary measures to achieve the processing objectives (eg avert a system threat, protection of public funds), is creating a pattern-processing arrangement is essential.
FCF sought the APA for the sole purpose of obtaining legal certainty, through an application process governed by a clear legal framework.
By virtue of the new Wills and Probate rules, individuals with assets in Dubai now will have the ability to register will in the English language that creates legal certainty for the inheritance of their assets after death.
Justice Minister Frances Fitzgerald said the new law would finally give legal certainty to those that the current one does not cover.
The 40% decrease in the ethanol price established by the government last August affected the cost structure of the company, which in a statement sent to the media said that the decision taken by the government "changes the rules of the Game and violates legal certainty.
The enactment of the Netting Law will create legal certainty in the DIFC as to the enforceability of close-out netting in the case of insolvency.
The day for finality and legal certainty in the long and difficult journey for equality is closer than ever before.
Furthermore we do now have legal certainty C even and especially for our customers.
The fact that the public's demand for legal certainty is being voiced louder than ever indicates that there is a significant problem in this area," HaE-im Kyylyyc said at a conference in the southern province of Antalya.
Peter DeFazio, Kurt Schrader and Greg Walden took the lead by co-authorin g the O&C Trust, Conservation and Jobs Act, which sets aside a majority of O&C lands into permanent conservation while placing a minority into an Oregon-managed trust to provide legal certainty for sustainable timber production.
The main objectives of an agreement would be an enhanced protection of EU investments in China and vice versa, improved legal certainty regarding the treatment of EU investors in China, said the ministers in a statement.
The appeal court disagreed, saying that "contrary to the submission on behalf of the appellants, the resulting situation is not lacking in legal certainty.