Letter Ruling

Also found in: Dictionary, Thesaurus, Financial, Acronyms, Encyclopedia.

Letter Ruling

In tax law a written interpretation of certain provisions of federal statutes by the Office of the Assistant Commissioner of the Internal Revenue Service.

Tax laws are often the subject of dispute between U.S. taxpayers and the Internal Revenue Service (IRS). Authority for interpreting the laws, which are found in the Internal Revenue Code, rests with regional IRS agents, who have the power to review tax returns through an audit. If a taxpayer disagrees with an interpretation of the law, she or he may ask the national IRS office to issue a ruling on the point of contention. This statement is called a private letter ruling.

Because of the time and expense involved in preparing a request for a letter ruling, such a request is seldom made. The taxpayer must submit a complete record of the transaction in dispute, including a justification for the transaction, all pertinent documents, the section of the tax code in question, and any relevant IRS regulations, rulings, and court precedents.

Letter rulings are issued by the Office of the Assistant Commissioner of the IRS. They are numbered—for example, Private Letter Ruling 8616003. Each discusses the applicable facts before the IRS as well as the IRS ruling, but does not name the individual or organization that requested the ruling. After the ruling is issued to the regional office and the taxpayer, it is published by the IRS. Several thousand letter rulings are issued annually.

The legal value of a letter ruling is extremely limited. The ruling applies only to the taxpayer who requested it and only for the year in which it is issued; federal tax law states that a letter ruling may not be used or cited by another taxpayer (I.R.C. § 6110(j)(3)). If the ruling favors the taxpayer, the regional IRS agent is bound by it. If the ruling is adverse, the taxpayer can submit the issue to a Tax Court.

Since the 1930s courts have refused to give precedential weight to letter rulings. In the 1989 case of Phi Delta Theta Fraternity v. Commissioner of Internal Revenue, 887 F.2d 1302 (6th Cir.), a national fraternity appealing an order of the U.S. Tax Court based part of its argument on several letter rulings. In affirming the Tax Court's decision, the appellate court described the weight courts are to give letter rulings: "Although private letter rulings are helpful in determining the contours of tax statutes and may be considered when evaluating the consistency of application of statutes, such letter rulings have no precedential effect."

Despite the limited application of letter rulings, they are widely read by tax attorneys. Specialists use them to keep abreast of IRS interpretation, and the documents are available from electronic databases.

Further readings

Banoff, Sheldon I., and Richard M. Lipton, eds. 1995. "Letter Ruling Held Relevant Authority in Malpractice Case." Journal of Taxation 82 (April).

Kanter, Burton W., and Sheldon I. Banoff, eds. 1992. "Associate Chief Counsel Speaks Out on Letter Rulings." Journal of Taxation 76 (January).


Income Tax; Taxation.

West's Encyclopedia of American Law, edition 2. Copyright 2008 The Gale Group, Inc. All rights reserved.
References in periodicals archive ?
A 2002 letter ruling suggests that an otherwise nontaxable partnership liquidation may be taxable when the partnership has an outstanding loan from the continuing owner.
In private letter ruling 9634007, the IRS said the publisher exercised sufficient control to create an employer-employee relationship for federal employment tax purposes.
After reviewing the initial rabbi trust ruling, this article discusses the tax issues involved, traces the evolution of the rabbi trust through a series of private letter rulings, and outlines key trust plan components.
A recent private letter ruling cast a cloud over the nontaxable status of B-type (as well as C-type) reorganizations in which the shareholders of the target corporation have been given "poison pill" rights to obtain stock in either the acquiring or the target corporation at a large discount in the event of a hostile takeover.
Because a letter ruling is the IRS's application of the tax law to the particular transaction described in a ruling request, it is "a holding of the IRS on that transaction only," so one taxpayer may not rely on a letter ruling issued to another taxpayer (revenue procedure 93-1).
(3) See, e.g., IRS Letter Rulings 200520020 (5/20/05), 200514004 (4/8/05), 200448004 (11/26/04) and 200441017 (10/8/04).
Facts: In Letter Ruling 200519042, the will provided that if the decedent's daughter disclaimed any of her inheritance, it would pass to a private foundation of which she and her husband were officers and directors.
The Service approaches the proper treatment of the structure in Letter Ruling 200430028 by implicitly asking whether the three members can be considered to operate on a cooperative basis.
Letter Ruling 200436011 (14) addressed the appropriate allocation of nonrecourse debt.
In Letter Ruling 9437034 (13) and TAM 9506004, (14) the IRS held that the proceeds of a personal injury lawsuit transferred to a special needs trust were the injured party's property, because he was also the trust beneficiary.
Even though the IRS continues to receive numerous late-filing letter ruling requests, (45) the number decreased substantially this year.