Mentioned in ?
References in periodicals archive ?
Leisinger, (31) which held that a permissive counterclaim did not relate back to the complaint and therefore did not toll the statute of limitations.
(96) A permissive counterclaim is defined by S.D.C.L.
(112) Despite the lack of a summons, (113) South Dakota has interpreted a permissive counterclaim to be commenced and subject to the applicable statute of limitations when filed within the answer.
(217) The court's explicit preclusion of relating back a counterclaim in Jacobson was specific to a permissive counterclaim. (218) South Dakota statutorily distinguishes between compulsory and permissive counterclaims; (219) such demarcations are drawn in Jacobson.
[section] 15-6-13(b) (2004) (stating the elements of a permissive counterclaim).
Verizon New England, Inc., the First Circuit addressed the issue of whether a federal court can properly exercise supplemental jurisdiction over a permissive counterclaim based on its relation to another counterclaim asserted by the defendant.
1984) (exercising jurisdiction over permissive counterclaim based on ancillary jurisdiction, not defensive "set-off exception); McCaffrey v.
In order for a United States federal district court to exercise jurisdiction over claims brought by a plaintiff, the claims must either be of sufficient federal substance, or be based on diversity between the parties with an amount in controversy exceeding $75,000 (1) When the parties are in federal court based on a federal question, the court's supplemental jurisdiction extends to other non-federal compulsory counterclaims that a defendant is required to bring, and the court may exercise jurisdiction over so called "permissive counterclaims" so long as they form part of the same Article III case or controversy as the original claim.
(13) Count two asserted that GNAP had commingled funds, and count three claimed "alter ego liability and disregard of the corporate form." (14) Count three required joining additional parties to the lawsuit: Global NAPs New Hampshire, Global NAPs Networks, Global NAPs Realty, Ferrous, a holding company, and Frank Gangi "[the] founder and sole shareholder of Ferrous." (15) After an unsuccessful attempt by GNAP to have counts two and three dismissed as permissive counterclaims, the court entered a default judgment for Verizon based on GNAP's discovery violations and held all of the defendants jointly and severally liable for the full amount of the judgment.
[section] 1367, district courts addressed compulsory and permissive counterclaims through what was deemed pendent and ancillary jurisdiction.
Kroger filed an unrelated permissive counterclaim for her husband's wrongful death based on diversity, there would be no supplemental jurisdiction over her claim against additional party Owen Equipment); see also id.
preclusion should not apply to such permissive counterclaims. (69) As