Ripeness


Also found in: Dictionary, Thesaurus, Idioms, Encyclopedia, Wikipedia.
Related to Ripeness: mootness

Ripeness

The mandate contained in Article III of the Constitution that requires an appellate court to consider whether a case has matured into a controversy worthy of adjudication before it can hear the case.

An actual, current controversy worthy of adjudication must exist before a federal court may hear a case. The court determines if a controversy between parties with adverse legal interests is of sufficient immediacy and reality to warrant judicial intervention (Lake Carriers' Ass'n v. MacMullan, 406 U.S. 498, 92 S. Ct. 1749, 32 L. Ed. 2d 257 [1972]).

The rationale behind the ripeness limitation is to prevent the courts from entering a controversy before it has solidified or before other available remedies have been exhausted. In disputes involving regulations or decisions promulgated by administrative agencies, a controversy is not considered ripe until the agency's decision has been formalized and the challenging parties have felt its effects. Similarly, if a state court remedy is available, a controversy is not ripe for federal court review until all state court remedies have been exhausted.

The courts generally apply a two-part test to determine if a controversy is ripe for judicial intervention. The first criterion is whether the controversy is fit for judicial decision, that is, whether it presents a Question of Law rather than a Question of Fact. Secondly, the courts determine the impact on the parties of withholding judicial consideration. In Abbott Laboratories v. Gardner, 387 U.S. 136, 87 S. Ct. 1507, 18 L. Ed. 2d 681 (1967), the Supreme Court examined whether a regulation that required drug manufacturers to use labels showing both the generic and the proprietary drug names was ripe for review before it was actually enforced. The Court held that the controversy was ripe because the regulation had an immediate and expensive impact on the plaintiffs' day-to-day operations and the plaintiffs risked a substantial sanction if they did not comply with the regulation.

Ripeness is a major consideration when parties seek injunctive or declarative relief before a statute or regulation has been applied. Courts are reluctant to enter an abstract disagreement over administrative policies (Ruckelshaus v. Monsanto, 467 U.S. 986, 104 S. Ct. 2862, 81 L. Ed. 2d 815 [1984]). However, in some cases, the courts will hear a request for an Injunction or Declaratory Judgment if the question presented is entirely or substantially legal and if postponing a decision until after a statute or regulation is applied would work a substantial hardship on the challenging party (Pacific Gas and Electric Co. v. State Energy Resources Conservation & Development Commission, 461 U.S. 190, 103 S. Ct. 1713, 75 L. Ed. 2d 752 [1983]).

Further readings

American Law Institute–American Bar Association (ALI ABA). 1996. The Ripeness Mess: Part I—Getting into State Court, by Michael M. Berger. Course of study, October 17, 1996. SB14 ALI-ABA 155.

——. 1993. The "Ripeness" Mess in the Federal Courts, by Michael M. Berger. Course of Study, September 30, 1993. C872 ALI-ABA 41.

Cross-references

Case or Controversy.

See: opportunity
References in periodicals archive ?
Gardeners and storage specialists are primarily interested in harvest and consumer ripeness. The first--to determine the timing of fruit harvesting in the garden and the latter--to determine storage time.
The objective of this study was to develop a three-dimensional finite element model to determine the natural frequencies and mode shapes of the coffee fruit-stem systems, considering different fruit ripeness. Moreover, it was carried out a theoretical study, using the finite element three-dimensional model, based on the linear theory of elasticity for determining the generated stress in a coffee fruit-stem system during the harvesting process by mechanical vibration.
"Endorsement of the agreement signifies the ripeness of all political groups," Shamkhani said on Tuesday.
SMELL: Medium intensity of ripeness aromas suggesting notes of pears, apples, yellow stone fruits, and minerals.
Wh| CRANBERRIES can be tested for ripeness by bouncing them.
Developed for farmers to test the ripeness of tehir product, medics have found it can detect the condition before symptoms appear.
UV concentration, degree of ripeness, postharvest storage conditions, and processing, each can significantly alter the amounts of nutrients and bioactive components.
Washington, Mar 31( ANI ): An electronic nose method has been developed which has been found to be useful in evaluating ripeness and flavour in fruits like melon.
Turkish Hazelnut Syrup delivers the intense toasty quality and deep nutty flavor of hazelnuts picked at their peak of ripeness and then naturally sun dried.
SUMMER is surely the season for peaches as they reach their optimal ripeness and become second to none in terms of taste.
Consumers are interested in the period of optimum ripeness for edibility of melons as they continue to ripen even after harvest.