Simultaneous Death

Also found in: Wikipedia.

Simultaneous Death

Loss of life by two or more individuals concurrently or pursuant to circumstances that render it impossible to ascertain who predeceased whom.

The issue of who died first frequently arises in cases determining the inheritance of property from spouses who die simultaneously. Generally the answer must be derived from all the surrounding circumstances. At Common Law, the law would not intervene and make the assumption that one individual or another had died first but would await proof, no matter how slight that might be. Since this created a problem when no satisfactory proof existed, various states enacted statutes allowing judges to presume that one individual survived another under certain circumstances.

Because those state statutes that created presumptions proved inadequate, a majority of the states enacted the Uniform Simultaneous Death Act. Although some slight variations exist from one state to another, the law essentially provides that property will be inherited or distributed as if each person had outlived the other. This prevents the property from passing into the estate of a second person who is already deceased only to be distributed immediately from that estate, a wasteful procedure that precipitates additional legal proceedings, costs, and estate taxes.

The Simultaneous Death Act cannot be applied if evidence exists that one individual outlived the other. The act only applies when it cannot be determined who died first. Ordinarily the persons involved need not have died in a common disaster but might have died in different places and under different circumstances, and it still might be impossible to prove that one survived the other. A 1985 Illinois case provides an example of where Simultaneous Death Act was held inapplicable because the court found it possible to ascertain who died first.

Janus v. Tarasewicz, 135 Ill.App.3d 936, 482 N.E.2d 418, 90 Ill.Dec. 599 (Ill.App. 1 Dist. 1985) arose out of a freakish series of events that began in the Chicago area in 1982. Adam Janus unluckily purchased a bottle of Tylenol capsules that had been laced with cyanide by an unknown perpetrator prior to its sale at retail. On the evening of September 29, 1982, the day of Adam's death, his brother, Stanley Janus, and Stanley's wife, Theresa Janus, having just returned from their honeymoon, gathered in mourning at Adam's home with other family members. Not yet knowing how Adam died, Stanley and Theresa innocently compounded the tragedy by taking some of the contaminated capsules themselves. Upon their arrival at the intensive care unit of a hospital emergency room, neither showed visible vital signs. Hospital personnel never succeeded in establishing any spontaneous blood pressure, pulse, or signs of respiration in Stanley and pronounced him dead. Hospital personnel did succeed in establishing a measurable, though unsatisfactory, blood pressure in Theresa. Although she had very unstable vital signs, remained in a coma, and had fixed and dilated pupils, she was placed on a mechanical respirator and remained on the respirator for two days before she was pronounced dead on October 1, 1982.

Stanley had a $100,000 life-insurance policy that named Theresa as primary beneficiary and his mother, Alojza Janus, as contingent beneficiary. The 1953 version of the Uniform Simultaneous Death Act, in force in Illinois, provides that if there is no sufficient evidence that the insured and beneficiary have died otherwise than simultaneously, the proceeds of the policy shall be distributed as if the insured had survived the beneficiary. The Illinois Court of Appeals held the act to be inapplicable because a preponderance of the evidence established that Theresa survived Stanley, albeit by only a couple of days. The result: the proceeds of Stanley's $100,000 policy did not go to his mother, Alojza, as contingent beneficiary, but to Theresa's father, Jan Tarasewicz, as administrator of her estate.

Further readings

Johnson, J. Rodney. 1994. "The New Uniform Simultaneous Death Act." Probate & Property 8 (May-June).

Waggoner, Lawrence W. 1994. "The Revised Uniform Probate Code." Trusts & Estates (May 1).


Death and Dying; Estate and Gift Taxes.

West's Encyclopedia of American Law, edition 2. Copyright 2008 The Gale Group, Inc. All rights reserved.
References in periodicals archive ?
Additionally, approximating the PMI in animal cases may be useful to court when considering such issues as duration of abuse or neglect, insurance fraud, harvest of game animals with relation to hunting season, or in cases in which there is simultaneous death of both animal and human.
EDINBURGH NIGHTS BBC2, 9.40pm James Kelman's latest novel, Dirt Road is about a Scottish family who are shattered by the nearly simultaneous death of mother and daughter from cancer.
Edinburgh Nights BBC2, 9.40pm James Kelman's latest novel, Dirt Road, is about a Scottish family who are shattered by the nearly simultaneous death of mother and daughter from cancer.
As the Founding Fathers well knew, once the forces of censorship are unleashed by government for politically desired ends, there is a simultaneous death of liberty and birth of tyranny.
Amnesty International said it was the "largest single batch of simultaneous death sentences we've seen in recent years, not just in Egypt but anywhere in the world," and called for the verdicts to be quashed.
Hassiba Hadj Sahraoui, deputy Middle East and North Africa programme director at Amnesty International, said: "This is the largest single batch of simultaneous death sentences we've seen in recent years, not just in Egypt but anywhere in the world." She added: "Egypt's courts are quick to punish Mohamed Morsi's supporters but ignore gross human rights violations by the security forces."
Can operation of the Uniform Simultaneous Death Act result in loss of the marital deduction?
The term "common disaster clause," also known as a "simultaneous death provision," has been loosely used to describe a variety of clauses dealing with presumptions as to the order of death of the insured and the beneficiary.
It now holds, in cases in which the presumption of the Uniform Simultaneous Death Act applies (i.e., that the insured survived the beneficiary), that the policy's interpolated terminal reserve is the appropriate measure of inclusion rather than the death benefit.
One area to be tackled is 'simultaneous death' where two people likely to inherit each other's property die in the same incident.
Thus Kristeva situates the simultaneous death of the symbolic order and the subject at a bio-psychical border whose fluctuations, originary source of the subject's experience of pleasure and pain, end in "nirvana." The corpse serves as material witness to the ambiguous relationship between fragmentation and "nirvana" in the structure of human life; abjection enables the subject to comprehend the corpse in the self.
Chapters cover such topics as Power of Attorney Act, International Wills Act, Intestacy, Wills and Donative Transfers, Nonprobate Transfers on Death Act, Trustee Powers Act, Simultaneous Death Act and TOD Security Registration Act.

Full browser ?