Visitation Rights

Visitation Rights

In a Divorce or custody action, permission granted by the court to a noncustodial parent to visit his or her child or children. Custody may also refer to visitation rights extended to grandparents.

In a divorce where one parent is awarded sole custody of the child, the noncustodial parent is usually awarded visitation rights in the divorce decree. Visitation rights can be withheld if evidence is provided that proves it is in the best interest of the child not to see the parent. This usually occurs only where it has been shown that the parent is an excessive user of alcohol, a user of illegal narcotics, or is physically or verbally abusive. With the large number of divorced parents in the United States, grandparents have lobbied successfully for laws that give them rights to visit their grandchildren. However, the U.S. Supreme Court has voiced concerns about such laws and ruled one such statute unconstitutional in 2000.

Visitation rights may be determined by the agreement of the parties or by a court order. If the court concludes that the parents will be cooperative, it may not issue a detailed visitation schedule. This means that parents must amicably work out reasonable times and terms that work best for both parents and child. If parents are not cooperative, the courts encourage the drafting of a detailed schedule that leaves no doubt about the frequency of visitation, the days and times of pickup and return, and holiday and vacation schedules.

Courts generally consider the wishes of the child when reviewing custody and visitation issues. A child's wish may be granted but it will be dependent on the child's age and maturity level, as well as what the court concludes is in the child's best interests. Courts also take into consideration the fact that the custodial parent may exert Undue Influence over the child's decision-making process and color the child's supposedly independent request. As children mature they may seek an order from the court changing custody and visitation arrangements.

A common problem in Family Law is when one parent uses visitation to spite the other parent. Examples include a custodial parent refusing visitation, not having the child available for the noncustodial parent at the appointed time for pickup, or a noncustodial parent not returning the child at the prescribed time. When a noncustodial parent encounters problems in exercising visitation rights, the parent may stop paying Child Support as a means of changing the custodial parent's behavior. However, the courts do not recognize this as a valid reason for withholding support, as visitation and support are separate and discrete issues. These circumstances, if persistent, sometimes lead the parents back into court for resolution of the problems.

When a substantial change in conduct or circumstances involving the parents occurs, the court may make permanent modifications in visitation rights. One of the parties must present clear evidence to the court of the change in conduct or circumstances. This evidence usually must be completely new to the court, as issues addressed in prior proceedings are generally not grounds for modification. Common grounds for permanent modifications include a persistent failure to follow the visitation schedule, repeated failure to return the child at the designated time, the teaching of immoral or illegal acts to the child, or the parent's conviction for a crime.

Visitation rights may also extend beyond parents. Every state has recognized grandparents' visitation rights in some form by amending visitation statutes. Several states limit visitation to cases where the parent is deceased, while others extend the right to cases of divorce, Annulment, or separation. Such laws have come under attack by parents, who argue that giving grandparents visitation rights infringes on their right to raise their children as they see fit. The U.S. Supreme Court, in Troxel v. Granville, 530 U.S. 57, 120 S.Ct. 2054, 147 L.Ed.2d 49 (2000), held that the state of Washington's grandparent visitation statute violated the due process clause of the Fourteenth Amendment, as it interfered with the rights of parents to make decisions concerning the care, custody, and control of their children. The statute permitted "any person" at "any time" to petition a state family court for visitation rights whenever "visitation may serve the best interest of the child."

Most states hold that the ongoing family is not subject to enforced intrusion by grandparents, if both parents are fit and object. A majority of states also hold that any Adoption preempts visitation by the natural grandparents and that grandparents generally have no right to intervene in an adoption proceeding involving their grandchild.

Further readings

Jackson, Anne Marie. 1994. "Coming of Age of Grandparent Visitation Rights." American University Law Review 43.

Krause, Harry D., and David D. Meyer. 2003. Family Law in a Nutshell. 4th ed. St. Paul, Minn.: West.

Sember, Brette McWhorter. 2002. The Visitation Handbook. Naperville, Ill.: Sphinx.

Cross-references

Child Custody; Children's Rights.

References in periodicals archive ?
(111) As in Quilloin, Michael's immediate concern was to ensure visitation rights with his daughter and thus protect his relationship with her.
In Part II, in order to provide context for my discussion of the possibility of awarding legal rights to paid caregivers, I describe the legal doctrines that provide custody and visitation rights to parties other than legal parents and the increasing legal recognition of functional parenthood in custody disputes and visitation petitions.
50 Cent won the right to regularly see his son in a court ruling yesterday.The 'Candy Shop' rapper was denied visitation rights to his son Marquise when he was accused of setting fire to the mansion Marquise was living in with his mother, 50's former girlfriend Shaniqua Tompkins.
The actor will have visitation rights and will pay child support.
A handsome stranger and runner of his own Landscaping business shows up and offers to buy the horse, and allow Sierra's three children visitation rights to the old gelding, and seems to be open to helping Sierra with her financial troubles.
Grandparents can't block custodial parents from moving out of state with a child even if the grandparents have visitation rights, the Arizona Court of Appeals ruled recently.
A JUDGE has awarded sole custody of Britney Spears' two young sons to ex-husband Kevin Federline and suspended the troubled US pop star's visitation rights.
TROUBLED pop star Britney Spears ran over a photographer's foot in her car just hours after losing visitation rights to her children, police said.
THE US judge in Britney Spears' custody battle yesterday told both sides to talk things over after the troubled singer sought expanded visitation rights. LA Superior Court commissioner Scott Gordon told lawyers for Spears and her ex-husband, Kevin Federline, to spend 45 minutes talking about what role Spears' mother and other relatives might play in visits with the children.
It led to her instructing lawyers at an Islamabad court to offer an out-of-court settlement for regular access through visitation rights for Molly.
Kim Basinger will go to trial in Los Angeles after pleading not guilty to disregarding court orders concerning ex-husband Alec Baldwin's visitation rights with their daughter.
(Colorado already has a fall ballot measure that would create a statewide registry for same-sex couples and give them many of the rights and benefits available to married couples, including health insurance, pension coverage, and hospital visitation rights.)