Crennan J contended that the impugned provisions 'operate to disentitle or exclude persons (otherwise legally eligible) from the right to vote and the right to participate in choosing parliamentary representatives for the state and subdivision in which they reside'.
Parents have expressed much consternation that child support and parenting time with children are distinct legal entities that do not work in tandem, when parents think they should; non-payment of child support does not automatically disentitle a parent to time with their child and refusal by one parent to allow the other parent time with their child does not automatically warrant or diminish the payment of child support.
Put another way, the insurers' settlement of the claim in this example and the presence of a follow the settlements clause in the contract of reinsurance should not disentitle the reinsurers from relying upon the warranties and exclusion clauses in their own contract of reinsurance in order validly to demonstrate that the claim so recognised by the insurers did not fall within the risks covered by the contract of reinsurance as a matter of law.
Likewise, when facing deteriorating economic performance, the CEO is more concerned with the expected personal costs of R&D spending, since poor performance may trigger such results as job termination and corporate takeover, which may disentitle the CEO to the future benefits of current R&D spending.
An analysis based on political powerlessness wrongly suggests that the gains in political solidarity of groups subjected to deep racial, sexist, or religious prejudice (in virtue of resistance to such prejudice) disentitle them from constitutional protection, as if the often meager political gains of blacks, women, and gays and lesbians (when measured against their claims of justice) are the measure of constitutional justice.
In announcing the unanimous decision, tribunal chairman Robert Ashton said: 'The decision to delay payment of the bonus was made unilaterally by the management and that should not disentitle Mr Evans to the payment.'