Impossibility


Also found in: Dictionary, Thesaurus, Encyclopedia, Wikipedia.
Related to Impossibility: Logical impossibility

Impossibility

A legal excuse or defense to an action for the breach of a contract; less frequently, a defense to a criminal charge of an attempted crime, such as attempted Robbery or murder.

Historically, a person who entered a contract was bound to perform according to his or her promised duties, regardless of whether it became impossible to do so. Thus, early U.S. courts did not recognize the defense of impossibility of performance. Courts noted that if the parties to a contract had desired to take into account any events that may develop after they reached an agreement, then they should have accounted for such contingencies in the contract.

As contract law developed over the twentieth century—and in response to increasing commercial activities—courts began to recognize impossibility as a valid defense to an action for breach of a contract. This defense did not normally apply if one party found it unexpectedly difficult or expensive to perform according to the contract; rather, it applied only when the basis or subject matter of the contract was destroyed or no longer existed. In addition, the defense of impossibility became available only if objective impossibility existed. Objective impossibility occurred when the contractual obligation could not actually be performed. Objective impossibility is often referred to by the statement "The thing cannot be done." For example, if a musician promised to play a concert at a specific concert hall but the concert hall subsequently burned down, it would be impossible to perform according to the contractual agreement and the musician would be excused from performing at that particular venue. Subjective impossibility exists when only one of the parties to a contract subjectively believes that she or he cannot complete the required performance. For example, if a musician believed that he had not practiced sufficiently to perform a successful concert, this belief would not excuse the musician from performing the concert. The statement "I cannot do it" frequently refers to the state of mind present in a case involving subjective impossibility.

Modern U.S. law uses the term impracticability synonymously with the term impossibility, primarily because some things may not be absolutely impossible to perform but are nevertheless impracticable to complete. Thus, the general rule is that a thing may be impossible to perform when it would not be practicable to perform. A contractual obligation is impracticable "when it can only be done at an excessive and unreasonable cost" (Transatlantic Financing Corp. v. United States, 363 F.2d 312 [D.C. Cir. 1966]).

When a party raises the defense of impracticability, courts generally determine three things: first, whether something unexpected occurred after the parties entered the contract; second, whether the parties had assumed that this thing would not occur; and third, that the unexpected occurrence made performance of the contract impracticable. Some widely recognized occurrences that would normally provide a defense of impracticability are the death or illness of one of the necessary parties, the unfore-seeable destruction of the subject matter of the contract (perhaps by an "act of God"), or a supervening illegality.Impossibility has been used as a defense to charges of attempted crimes. Historically, courts recognized that a party could not be convicted of criminal attempt if the actual crime was legally impossible to accomplish. For example, if a person was accused of attempting to receive stolen property but the property was not actually stolen, the defense of legal impossibility could arise. Legal impossibility is distinguished from factual impossibility, where facts unknown to the person attempting to commit a crime render the crime factually impossible to complete. For example, if a pickpocket attempts to steal a wallet but no wallet is present, factual impossibility may exist. Courts generally have recognized legal impossibility as a defense to a criminal attempt, but not factual impossibility. They reasoned that since a person attempting to commit a crime had formed the required intent to commit the crime, it was irrelevant that the crime was factually impossible to complete.

Impossibility as a defense to a criminal attempt has largely been rejected by modern U.S. statutes and courts. The Model Penal Code—which many states have adopted since its introduction in 1962—expressly rejects impossibility as a defense to the charge of criminal attempt (§ 5.01 [1995]).

Further readings

Bello, Christopher. 1985. "Construction and Application of State Statute Governing Impossibility of Consummation as Defense to Prosecution for Attempt to Commit Crime." American Law Review 41.

Berliant, Marcus, and Paul Rothstein. 2003. "Possibility, Impossibility, and History in the Origins of the Marriage Tax." National Tax Journal 56 (June).

"Modern Status of the Rules Regarding Impossibility of Performance as Defense in Action for Breach of Contract." 1962. American Law Reports 84.

impossibility

n. when an act cannot be performed due to nature, physical impediments, or unforeseen events. It can be a legitimate basis to rescind (mutually cancel) a contract. (See: contract)

IMPOSSIBILITY. The character of that which. cannot be done agreeably to the accustomed order of nature.
     2. It is a maxim that no one is bound to perform an impossibility. A l'impossible nul n'est tenu. 1 Swift's Dig. 93; 6 Toull. n. 121, 481.
     3. As to impossible conditions in contracts, see Bac. Ab. Conditions, M; Co. Litt. 206; Roll. Ab. 420; 6 Toull. n. 486, 686; Dig. 2, 14, 39; Id. 44, 7, 31; Id. 50, 17, 185; Id. 45, 1, 69. On the subject of impossible conditions in wills, vide 1 Rop. Leg. 505; Swinb. pt. 4, s. 6; 6 Toull. 614. Vide, generally, Dane's Ab. Index, h.t.; Clef des Lois Rom. par Fieffe Lacroix, h.t.; Com. Dig. Conditions, D 1 & 2; Vin. Ab. Conditions, C a, D a, E a.

References in periodicals archive ?
The Union Finance Minister further wrote that the Congress' manifesto comprised of two important limbs - a constitutional impossibility and a fiscal impossibility.
In other words, the risk in contractual matters has to be analysed: from the perspective of the fortuitous impossiblity of performance--where the solution of the risk bearing problem is offered by the remedies for failure of performance provided for by the Romanian Civil Code and from the special perspective of contracts transferring onwnership as impossibility of performance is sometimes linked to the fortuitous loss of the good--object of the contract (Pop, Popa, Vidu, 2012: 323-326).
The idea behind impossibility structures--that the government could
Hitting back at criticism that his party was using its veto to disregard the wishes of an entire sect, Aoun reiterated his belief that the Sunnis had many qualified people but stressed the "impossibility" of cooperating with any government headed by Hariri.
Plaintiff argued that the 2008 global credit crisis, which it claimed prevented Younan from obtaining commercially practicable financing, excused it from performing under the contract pursuant to the doctrine of impossibility of performance.
In other words, if Something from Nothing were only a physical impossibility, we could well say that God could do it, create in this manner.
1 : something that cannot be done or occur <Time travel is an impossibility.>
As for the "alleged impossibility of applying the Commission's decisions," Spain failed to prove that it found itself in the virtual impossibility of executing these decisions.
VAMPIRES ARE A STATISTICAL IMPOSSIBILITY SAYS SCIENTIST
The impossibility of its division in actuality is because of the inability of infinity to come out from force (min al-quwwah) to actuality.
Although counting dead animals in the African bush is a practical impossibility, researchers in the Congo were well positioned to quantify the recent outbreak.
Evidence is clearly presented to illustrate the impossibility of attaining any dream of star-settlement.