weight of evidence

Also found in: Acronyms.

Weight of Evidence

Measure of credible proof on one side of a dispute as compared with the credible proof on the other, particularly the Probative evidence considered by a judge or jury during a trial.

The trier of fact in a civil or criminal trial, whether a judge or a jury, must review the evidence presented, evaluate it, and determine if it meets the standard of proof. If it meets this standard, the trier of fact must return a verdict in favor of the plaintiff in a civil suit and must convict a defendant in a criminal trial. If the evidence does not meet the standard of proof, the trier of fact must find for the defendant in a civil or criminal case. These decisions are based on the concept of the "weight of evidence."

The weight of evidence is based on the believability or persuasiveness of evidence. The probative value (tending to convince a person of the truth of some proposition) of evidence does not necessarily turn on the number of witnesses called, but rather the persuasiveness of their testimony. For example, a witness may give uncorroborated but apparently honest and sincere testimony that commands belief, even though several witnesses of apparent respectability may contradict her. The question for the jury is not which side has more witnesses, but what testimony they believe.

Particular evidence has different weight in inducing belief with respect to the facts and circumstances to be proved. Evidence that is indefinite, vague, or improbable will be given less weight than evidence that is direct and unrefuted. For example, a criminal defendant's testimony that he had never been at the scene of a crime would be given little weight if his fingerprints were found at the crime scene and witnesses testify they saw him at the scene. Similarly, evidence given by a witness who testifies from personal observation is of greater weight than evidence offered by a witness who is testifying from general knowledge alone.

In a civil trial, the plaintiff's Burden of Proof is the preponderance of the evidence standard, which means that the plaintiff must convince the trier of fact that the evidence in support of his case outweighs the evidence offered by the defendant to oppose it. In contrast, criminal trials require that the weight of evidence proving a defendant's guilt must be Beyond a Reasonable Doubt.In a number of jurisdictions, judges are prohibited from instructing juries on the weight to be given to evidence. In other states, the judge is permitted to give a balanced and fair assessment of the weight she believes should be ascribed to the evidence. All jurisdictions prohibit the judge from instructing the jury on what weight is to be given to the testimony of any witness or class of witnesses. The judge may not state that any particular piece of admissible evidence is or is not entitled to receive weight or consideration from the jury. The judge is also forbidden either to aid a jury or to infringe upon its role in weighing the evidence or in deciding upon the facts. In addition, the judge, in giving her instructions to the jury, has no right to prescribe the order and manner in which the evidence should be examined and weighed by the jury, or to tell the jurors how they shall consider any evidence that has been received by the court.


Preponderance of Evidence.

West's Encyclopedia of American Law, edition 2. Copyright 2008 The Gale Group, Inc. All rights reserved.

weight of evidence

n. the strength, value and believability of evidence presented on a factual issue by one side as compared to evidence introduced by the other side. (See: evidence, preponderance of the evidence)

Copyright © 1981-2005 by Gerald N. Hill and Kathleen T. Hill. All Right reserved.

weight of evidence

the degree of reliance that a court places on a piece of evidence.
Collins Dictionary of Law © W.J. Stewart, 2006

WEIGHT OF EVIDENCE. This phrase is used to signify that the proof on one side, of a cause is greater than on the other.
     2. When a verdict has been rendered against the weight of the evidence, the court may, on this ground, grant a new trial, but the court will exercise this power not merely with a cautious, but a strict and sure judgment, before they send the case to a second jury.
     3. The general rule under such circumstances is, that the verdict once found shall stand: the setting aside is the exception, and ought to be an exception, of rare and almost singular occurrence. A new trial will be granted on this ground for either party; the evidence, however, is not to be weighed in golden scales. 2 Hodg. R. 125; S. C. 3 Bing. N. C. 109; Gilp. 356; 4 Yeates, 437; 3 Greenl. 276; 8 Pick. 122; 5 Wend. 595; 7 Wend. 380; 2 Vir. Cas. 235.

A Law Dictionary, Adapted to the Constitution and Laws of the United States. By John Bouvier. Published 1856.
References in periodicals archive ?
"My whole career is based on this idea of weight of evidence, or systematic review," said Goodman, who along with colleagues at Gradient has looked at dozens of different ways of conducting such reviews.
It would seem to me that the weight of evidence suggests this state of affairs is leading directly to underperformance in terms of profit.
'The study adds to the weight of evidence that exposure to low levels of PCBs is inversely associated with fetal growth.
FA chairman David Bernstein said: "It is essential that we determine as soon as possible the weight of evidence behind these serious allegations .
Tsacheva nevertheless expressed concern that there should be such discrepancy between the view of the prosecution and that of courts regarding the weight of evidence against accused persons.
These chemicals will receive special restrictions and the commissioners stressed 'all available information is to be considered and in a so-called 'weight of evidence approach'' when deciding which substances will be categorised.
The weight of evidence gathered by investigators forced him to admit laundering pounds 1million of drug money.
Robert Hammond, energy expert for Consumer Focus, said: "The fact that wholesale prices are at a three-year low adds further to the already heavy weight of evidence that greater energy price cuts are needed.
"We believe there should be a minimum price for alcohol, given the weight of evidence linking pricing with the amount people drink."
Depictions of cigarette smoking are pervasive in movies; they occur in three-quarters or more of contemporary box office hits, the NCI report said, adding that the weight of evidence indicates a causal relationship between exposure to depictions of smoking in movies and youth smoking initiation.
An examination of the weight of evidence across all of the available studies was conducted to enable a comprehensive assessment of potential risk.
WHEN I was appointed as leader of Stockton Council, following the elections in 2007, I said I would base my decisions and recommendations on the weight of evidence and the strength of debate.